Annie Leibovitz
A Photographers Life
In professional terms, there are two types of photographers. There are those for which
photography is a career, who have an office from where they conduct their business, a
studio where they undertake commissions, a business card and a letterhead and a glossy
portfolio full of photographs they’ve been paid to create. At the end of the day this
photographer packs away their camera, heads for the Bundy Clock and locks the search
for captivating imagery away until he or she clocks back on the following day. For this
photographer, it is a job; nothing more. Then there are those who live photography, who
never fail to be without their camera, who, after collecting their day’s wage continue to
consider and critically observe the visual world around them.
Annie Leibovitz, whose retrospective exhibition, A Photographers Life 1990 – 2005 has
just opened at The Museum of Contemporary Art in Sydney is a photographer of the
latter variety.
As famous for the work she has performed throughout her career for Vanity Fair and
Vogue, as those at whom she has aimed her camera, in A Photographers Life we are
invited into a world beyond Hollywood, beyond the glamour, pomp and sycophancy of
celebrity and into Annie Leibovitz’s life.
So it is in conjunction with the work for which we know her so well - her commercial
work, that we now bare witness to a world which until now, Leibovitz was fairly adamant
about keeping to herself. We are privy to moments of rare intimacy – moments of birth,
relationships, loss, struggle, love and almost predictably, death. Pivotal to this diarised
aspect of the exhibition is Leibovitz’s relationship with the self-professed “freelance
intellectual” and novelist, the late Susan Sontag and to a slightly lesser extent, her
immediate family. As well as this side of her personal work we’re also introduced to her
short-lived move into photojournalism and a suite of more spacious and introspective
landscape photographs.
For most people Leibovitz’s elaborately staged, manicured and fastidiously directed
images will spring to mind upon the mention of her name. Many of these works, of
subjects such as Nicole Kidman, Julianne Moore, The White Stripes, Scarlett Johansson,
Leigh Bowery, Donald Trump, Queen Elizabeth II and perhaps most infamously, a
pregnant Demi Moore are included in the show and rightly so. It is after all, if only for a
fraction of the dubiously titled, ‘Photographers Life’ (the exhibition represents a 15 year
period of her life), somewhat of a visual biography. That she has included this career
driven work, when many artists’ personal and professional facades are often dichotomous,
gives viewers a sense of equilibrium between work and play. However, it must be said
that in terms of her professional work, these portraits and others like them direct more
curiosity toward the creation of the image than to the subjects themselves. You can spot
camera equipment junkies - eye to eye with George W. Bush - attempting to count the
number of strobes used; where wind machines were placed for Uma Thurman; how many
assistants were required; what was done in post production etc, etc. In one case, Queen
Elizabeth II’s portrait, the location is seemingly the wintry gardens of Buckingham
Palace. However - and I should note that Leibovitz is freely forthcoming with such
information - in this case we are dealt a valuable lesson in modern photographic reality.
The Queen, who had refused to go outside to be photographed, was shot on a grey
backdrop inside the Palace which was later digitally exchanged for the Palace Gardens –
shot days prior. To an audience largely unaware of such manipulation, this is misleading
and very much a contribution the slippery slope of existential modification.
It is with this in mind that I want to point to and highlight the importance and necessity
for honesty in portraiture as well as photography in general. And conveniently enough,
we need look no further than Annie Leibovitz herself for myriad examples upon which to
base such a paradigm.
The first portrait which struck me for its integrity was a diptych of the American, William
S. Burroughs. Photographed in the garage of the writer’s Kansas home, Leibovitz, with
only the lighting afforded her by the open garage door places Burroughs in a familiar,
comfortable environment and directs our gaze nowhere but into and beyond the face of
this subversive genius.
The next arresting portrait is of the photographer’s mother. Again a gentle, black and
white portrait where the focus in both senses of the word is solely on the subject – an
elderly face, a tussle of greying hair, a chest bespeckled by the sun and with it all, a
summoning of pathos that might be conjured by a portrait of one’s own mother.
Two other portraits of similar triumph, one of Eudora Welty, a Pulitzer Prize-winning
author and the unlikely philanthropist Oseola McCarty are once again made at the homes
of the respective sitters. Welty, photographed in colour and showing the fragility and
vulnerability of her age, clutches the arm of an antique chair while drawing the lapels of
her overcoat together in response to the chill of early spring. The lighting is so subtle it is
almost indefinable but more importantly, unobtrusive. In her portrait guise, this is
Leibovitz at her best – when subject rules over process.
One of the finest images in the exhibition, taken in 1996, harks back to the style of
Leibovitz’ early years when she toured with The Rolling Stones in the mid-seventies. The
intimate, homely scene of Patti Smith reclined on a mattress while her children Jackson
and Jesse pick at a guitar and nurse the family cat is as honest and observant as those
early vignettes of Mick Jagger, Keith Richards and co. The scene also bares a striking
resemblance to the image adorning the cover of world renowned photojournalist, Eugene
Richards’ book Dorchester Days taken some decades earlier and indicates Leibovitz’
early influences - Robert Frank and Henri Cartier-Bresson. Again, when the subject is
given priority over the process, the result, albeit discreet is a success.
Such intimacy, while apparent in all of her sittings with regulars such as Smith and
Jagger is incomparable however to the relationship she shared with Susan Sontag and the
veracious nature in which she went about portraying her lover. They are photographs
much like those that photographers the world over might have tucked away in shoeboxes
never to be seen by another outside of that immediate relationship. The exhibition of such
personal events a tribute or homage to a muse, especially in this case considering
Sontag’s passing.
To track sideways, as Leibovitz has done with the inclusion of a couple of images in the
exhibition, it’s interesting to see a couple of forays into photojournalism intertwined with
the softer, more pensive subjects aforementioned. The two I speak of are both from
1993/4; one from Rwanda, the other from the besieged Capital of Bosnia, Sarajevo. In
one grainy, 35mm black and white print, its mother negative has been processed hastily
with areas of higher density draining from the sprocket holes of the film where chemical
developer has rushed through in an overzealous developing process. An abandoned
bicycle lies on the road with an ellipse of smeared blood encircling it. The blood
belonged to a young boy who had been wounded by a Serb mortar shell while riding. He
didn’t survive. This single photograph is allegorical of a wider issue and bears a subtlety
often overlooked by war-hardened photojournalists. The problem is that this is the only
image that remotely points to the cause that one would presume Leibovitz was aiming to
draw attention to. The others in the exhibition, with the exception of an image of a
wounded man in the operating room of a Sarajevo Hospital which includes the presence
of another photographer in the background and reeks of ‘photo-opportunity’, are not only
insufficient but detached from the tragedy that had befallen the city. One wonders
whether visiting a war-zone on the back of Sontag who was working on a theatre
production was merely a holiday or a box-ticking exercise rather than a serious attempt at
reportage.
Returning to her strengths and to Sontag (whom she had accompanied to Sarajevo)
viewers are given a chronology of the late writers final years of life. In shared moments
in hotel rooms, at work, in hospital beds, in the studio and unflinchingly, in death,
Sontag’s life and to an extent their lives are posthumously laid bare.
The task of photographing a loved one through the journey of death is without doubt the
hardest of undertakings. For Leibovitz, whose job it has been to present her subjects in
guises more glamorous than reality generally allows, this must have been particularly
confronting. Sontag is as willing a participant as Leibovitz is objective throughout and
beyond the time that Sontag was alive to grant her unspoken consent.
One of the most striking portraits of Sontag was taken across the road from their Paris
apartment on the Seine a year before her death. Shot for the jacket of Sontag’s book,
Regarding the Pain of Others; it is an ominous portrayal. Perhaps this sense of
foreboding is heightened because we are already aware of Sontag’s fate but nonetheless
Leibovitz has again maintained her honesty towards photographing those closest to her
and revealed a stoic yet frightened and perhaps resigned Sontag. Also in this image we
see the use of one of Leibovitz’ oft-drawn upon methods - the David Hockney-esque
paneling of multiple photographs. In this case we are granted an out-of-focus but
instantly recognisable glimpse of The Seine and beyond it, the arched Pont Neuf on a
typically melancholic, winter’s day in Paris.
In an unfortunate but cyclical coincidence, Leibovitz documents not only with the death
of her lover and a month later her father but her own pregnancy and the lives of her new
born. It is with the latter that we see a touching sequence of three images depicting
affectionate scenes two days prior to, the day of and the day following his death. One
cannot help but be moved.
Finally, and with by far the largest prints in the exhibition, Leibovitz presents her
landscapes. Again she adopts a grainy, low-key, black and white aesthetic but in this
instance uses a more technically impressionistic approach. A preoccupation with fog and
mist is evident with almost horizon-free panoramas in Venice hanging beside ghostly,
twisted trees from rural New York State and a mosaic of foliage crawling like urban
sprawl across a Temple wall in Japan. These are all quiet, lonely observations and
although the dates of their shooting run throughout much of the 15 year span, one might
assume that the act of seeing and capturing these vistas is a cathartic process and one
which provides a much needed counterbalance to ‘work’. It is one of the most visually
pleasant rooms in the exhibition this one. With only half a dozen or so prints, it has a
continuity that sometimes lacks in other parts of the show. The negatives from which the
images have come have been stretched to capacity to produce images of such grandeur
and for the technical buff this might seem a mistake. However, together with the chosen
subject matter and the free and almost haphazard fashion in which they were captured,
the pebble-like grain is not inappropriate.
When looking at Liebovitz’s exhibition it is vital to consider the work without
succumbing to the awe and hyperbole that surrounding everything she points a camera at.
It needs to be said that by the time any artist reaches the levels of success that Leibovitz
has, almost anything that he or she undertakes thereafter is looked upon with elevated
importance. Therefore one needs to be especially discerning to make an objective
assessment. This is as true for the wider audience as it is for your reviewer.
Having a famous personality in a photograph does not mean it is a good photograph.
Having said that though, one must remember that to be in a position to be photographing
such personalities, the photographer, without question has paid their dues.
There is no question that Leibovitz is a great photographer. She has proved herself time
and again over the past decades and her abilities continue to be highly sought after the
world over. However, for an audience that will most likely be attracted to the MCA by
her reputation as the photographer to the stars, one must not give unconditional credence
to the other half of her work. Much of this work is worthy of no more or less credit than
the many hundreds of lesser-known photographers such as Larry Towell with the work
from his book, The World From My Front Porch (Boot 2008) or even the Australian,
Trent Parke with his series, The Christmas Tree Bucket, who both tackle similar themes
of friends and family to far less fanfare.
Of any genre, Annie Leibovitz is of course one of, if not the tallest of poppies in the
current crop of international photographers. For an Australian audience notorious for its
propensity towards the harvesting of them, it will be interesting to see the response to A
Photographers Life.
